The Mushroom Mistress
Shop Now

About Us

Nestled in the heart of Arcadia Indiana, The Mushroom Mistress is a haven for mushroom enthusiasts seeking top-quality Nilla oysters, snow oysters, lions mane, and king trumpet mushrooms. Our passion for fungi shines through in every delectable offering, including our dehydrated oyster mushrooms and lions mane powder. Visit us at 406 W South St or contact us at to elevate your culinary creations with our exceptional mushroom products.

Where can you find us?

Find us with Simply From Scratch Weekly at multiple different locations!
June  July 

Meet Our Team

Introducing the passionate individuals behind The Mushroom Mistress, committed to quality and flavor in every product.

LindsEy Tinch

The Mistress

The founder and visionary, Lindsey ensures every mushroom is grown with care and expertise.

mike Tinch

Our cultivation guru, Mike specializes in growing the finest oyster and lion's mane mushrooms.

Emma Tinch

The quality control expert, Emma guarantees that every product meets our high standards before reaching you.